Tuesday, 14 June 2016

Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake

Inspired by the classic ice cream, this Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake is easy to make & rewards you with a delicious dessert containing a medley of flavours!  

Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake Recipe

As a child I was never particularly keen on ice cream!  Yes, I was a fussy child, but I would always manage to make an exception for Neapolitan Ice Cream.  The triple striped layer of vanilla, strawberry & chocolate always enticed me.  It was simply far more exciting and tasty than plain old vanilla.  Having bought a block of the ice cream the other week the idea of a Neapolitan Cheesecake came to mind.  The thought of the classic Neapolitan flavours - chocolate, vanilla and strawberry - layered in a baked cheesecake meant that such a dessert was soon going to be adorning our dining table!

Before making our Neapolitan cheesecake, I undertook a brief Google search to identify any defined order for arranging the three Neapolitan layers.  It appears there isn't, although the vast majority appear to position the vanilla centrally during the layering process.   I also discovered, having read Ice cream History, that the popular Neapolitan ice cream was created in Italy way back in the early 19th century.  It was introduced to America in the 1870s from Italian immigrants who called the triple layered block ice cream Spumoni.
How to make a Neapolitan Cheesecake

Now, the eagle eyed amongst you will have noticed that the strawberry layer is in fact a set strawberry coulis rather than cheesecake.  The intention had been to construct all three layers with a delicious creamy cheesecake but during the layering up process it soon became evident that the vanilla layer, which I wanted to sit between the strawberry and chocolate layers to make the colours more distinctive, was too soft to be able to support the strawberry layer.  So, deciding not to risk spoiling our Neapolitan Cheesecake dessert I compromised and baked it with just the chocolate & vanilla layers.  The strawberry layer was then applied as a soft set jelly just before serving, in much the same way as I did with our Bilberry and White Chocolate Cheesecake.  Although it would have been nice to have had all three layers as a cheesecake, I was still more than happy with the result, both visually and on the pallet.          

Neapolitan Cheesecake with chocolate, vanilla and strawberries

The lovely hue arising from the set strawberry coulis certainly gives this Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake enough presence to be served as it is.  Though, if you want to make the dessert appear a little more special a few piped rosettes of Chantilly cream really does the trick especially when finished with a handful of fresh strawberries.  And if you fancy going a step further, those strawberries would look great dipped in melted chocolate!

How to make a Neapolitan Cheesecake

This Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake is made with a digestive biscuit base, topped with a milk chocolate cheesecake layer and followed with a delicious vanilla cheesecake mix.  A soft set strawberry coulis completes the dessert, bringing extra freshness and a lovely strawberry flavour. 

So let's get to it and bake.

Baked Neapolitan Cheesecake     Yum

Neapolitan Cheesecake recipe
Yield: 1 cheesecake 
Serves: 10 - 12 good slices
Difficulty: Easy
Time: hands on time about 30 minutes; plus 60 - 65 total bake time; plus cooling and chilling time.

You will need:

1 x 20cm spring form cake tin (ideally lip free)
Greaseproof Paper
Tin Foil
Medium Pan
Mixing Bowls
Electric Beaters (ideal, though not essential)
Roasting Tin large enough to sit the cake tin in
Balloon Whisk
Piping Bag (optional)
Star Piping Nozzle (optional)

For the Biscuit Base

220g Digestive Biscuits
70g Unsalted Butter, cubed, plus extra for greasing

For the Cheesecake Layers

600g Cream Cheese, full fat & good quality
150g Sour Cream
2 large Eggs, lightly beaten
1 Lemon, Zest of
60g Milk Chocolate, melted
1 capful Vanilla Extract
1.5 tbsp Golden Caster Sugar

Strawberry Layer and Decoration

400g (approx.) Fresh Strawberries
3 tbsp Water
1 x sachet Vegetarian Gelling Powder (we used Dr Oetker's Vege-Gel)
100ml cold Water
100ml Double Cream
1 tsp Icing Sugar
1 capful Vanilla Extract

How to make it:

1.  Pre-heat the oven to 170c / Fan 150c / Gas 3.

2.  Prepare the cake tin.  Grease and fully line your cake tin with greaseproof paper.  Cut a strip of tinfoil around 40cm long.  Sit the cake tin in the centre of it.  Bring the tin foil up the side of the tin, and scrunch to secure.  The tin foil needs to come at least half way up the sides of the tin.   

3.  Make the base.  Place the butter into a medium pan and set over a gentle flame to melt.  Meanwhile, crush the biscuits either in a food processor or encase them in a clean tea towel (perhaps in two batches) and use a rolling pin or can to crush them until they are a sandy consistency.  Pour the biscuit crumbs into the melted butter.  Mix until all of the biscuits crumbs have been coated in the butter.  Tip into the prepared cake tin and smooth out.  Press it down with the back of a teaspoon to compact the mixture.  Place into the oven and bake for 10 minutes.  Remove from the oven and allow to cool.  Keep the oven on, set at the same temperature.

4.  Start making the cream-cheese body.  Place the cream-cheese into a large bowl and beat with the electric beaters (or by hand with a wooden spoon) on a slow setting for 1 or 2 minutes (see note b).  Add the sour cream and lemon zest and beat again.  Add the beaten eggs in two stages, beating well after each addition.  Decant half of the cream cheese mixture into another bowl.    

5.  Flavour the two cheesecakes.  Add the slightly cooled melted milk chocolate into one of the bowls.  Mix until the chocolate is well combined with the cream cheese.  Add the vanilla and sugar to the other mixture and mix well.  

6.  Decant into the cake tin.  Pour the chocolate cheesecake mixture onto the biscuit base.  Carefully level the mixture out with the back of a teaspoon aiming to avoid disturbing the biscuit crumb.  Gently spoon the vanilla mixture on top of the chocolate layer.  Level the mixture out, again aiming not to disturb the chocolate layer beneath.

7.  Bake and cool.  Place the cake tin into a roasting tin and position it in the centre of the oven.  Pour water into the roasting tin so that it comes half way up the side of the cake tin, though not beyond the top of the tin foil.  Bake for 10 minutes.  Reduce the oven temperature to 140c / Fan 120c/ Gas 1 for a further 40 - 45 minutes.  The cheesecake will still have a slight wobble in the centre when it is ready.  At this point, turn the oven off leaving the cheesecake in the oven for a further 2 hours sat in the water bath.  This will help it cool down slowly and hopefully avoid a crack developing in the top.  After  2 hours remove from the oven and roasting tin.   Once fully cold, cover and place in the fridge for at least 6 hours.

8.  Prepare the strawberry topping.  Wash the strawberries.  Set aside a few nice small ones to decorate the top of the cheesecake.  Chop the remainder of the berries and place into a small pan with about 3 tablespoons of water.  Sit over a medium heat and allow them to cook and release their juice into the water, stir periodically.  Measure 100ml of cold water into a cup or jug and add roughly half of the powder from the vegetarian gelling sachet.  Add this to the strawberry mixture and stir to combine.  Allow it to come back to the boil.  Remove from the heat. (see note c below.)

9.  Add the strawberry layer to the cheesecake.  Sit the bottom third of the pan in a bowl of cold water to encourage the jelly mixture to cool down, stirring constantly.  Finger test the heat of the mixture and once cool enough spoon it over the top of the cold cheesecake.  Work quickly as the vegetarian jelly sets very quickly.

10.   Remove your cheesecake from the tin.  Remove the tinfoil from the sides of the tin.  Unclip the cake tin, loosening it to reveal the cake.  Gently peel away the grease proof paper.   Transfer to your chosen cake stand or plate. (see note d below.)

11.  Decorate with chantilly cream and strawberries.  Pour the double cream into a bowl.  Add the vanilla extract and icing sugar.  With a balloon whisk, whisk until it has reached soft peak stage.  Avoid over whisking.    Spoon into a piping bag fitted with a star nozzle and pipe rosettes around the edge of the cake.  Alternatively use a teaspoon to blob small mounds of the cream on the cheesecake.  Top with fresh strawberries.



a)  The tinfoil will help prevent any water from entering the cake tin and spoiling the cheesecake whilst it sits in the water bath.
b) Aim to beat the cheesecake mixture rather than whip it, as the latter is more likely to incorporate air into the mixture resulting in a bake which is less smooth.
c) We used Dr Oekter's Vege-Gel to set the strawberry topping.  It's easily found in the baking aisle of most supermarkets, but should you use another brand you may need to prepare and use it in a different way.
d)  A lip free spring-form cake tin will make it easier to transfer the cheesecake to your serving plate.  However, if the base of your cake tin has a lip, like ours, you may find it easiest to keep the cheesecake on the base rather than risk breaking the cheesecake during the tricky transfer.  To prevent the base of the cake tin moving around on your chosen cake stand / plate, simply sit it on a piece of folded kitchen roll.
e) Consider dipping the fresh strawberries in melted chocolate before decorating the top of the cheesecake. 

Pin-it for later....

Inspired by the classic Neapolitan Icecream, this baked Neapolitan cheesecake consists of a biscuit base, a layer of chocolate cheesecake which is topped with vanilla cheesecake.  The final layer is a set strawberry vegetarian jelly.


This post has been shared with: 

Bake of the Week co-hosted by Helen at Casa Costello and Sarah at Maison Cupcake, this week hosted by Helen.


  1. This looks lovely, Angela. I, like you, used to love Neapolitan ice cream as a kid. We hardly every had it so it used to be a huge treat...I love the way you have used the idea in a cheesecake - so creative! Eb x

    1. We were just the same Eb, Neapolitan was rarely bought but when we did have some my brother and I would always be so excited!
      Thanks for your lovely comment Eb, as always,
      Angela x

  2. We've got a box of neopolitan in the freezer at the moment and the kids are loving it! Your cheesecake version sounds gorgeous. I think my adult tastes would much prefer it to the ice cream' #cookblogshare

    1. It's funny how our tastes change as we get a little older isn't it? We enjoyed our ice cream but we weren't giddy excited as we would have been had we been 8 again :-)
      Thank for your lovely comment Mandy,
      Angela x

  3. It looks beautiful and a great idea for a cheesecake as chocolate, strawberry and vanilla is a lovely combination! I remember neapolitan ice cream being really exciting when I was younger as we normally only had plain vanilla in the freezer!

    1. Thank you Corina :-) The flavours work so well together don't they? We too usually only had vanilla ice cream so when Neapolitan (and raspberry ripple) was bought it always seemed like a special occasion.
      Thanks for your lovely comment,#
      Angela x

  4. Wow this looks tasty :-) Thanks for sharing with #CookBlogShare

    1. Thank you Hayley. I shared a slice with our elderly neightbour and she passed comment yesterday about how much she enjoyed it.
      Thanks for popping by and commenting,
      Angela x

  5. what a genius way of making this cheesecake based on Neapolitan ice cream. i think the fresh strawberry coulis looks great and is a great additon to the other two cheesecake layers. xx

    1. Aw thank you Jenny, I'll take genius any day -haha :-) The strawberry layer really brought a lovely freshness to the cheesecake making it a little less rich.
      Thanks for your lovely comment Jenny,
      Angela x

  6. This looks lovely. I have only tried baked ones a couple of times and either overcooked them or tried to make them too healthy (using quark) as they were quite dry #cookblogshare

    1. Thank you Louise :-) I must admit that this is only my second baked cheesecake too, I absolutely love them but given that OH isn't a fan I tend not to make them. I've not tried a 'healthy' cheesecake, would that mean I could have two slices though ;-)
      Thanks for your lovely comment,
      Angela x


Thank you for spending your time reading my recipe posts. You're invited to leave a comment, thought or suggestion, all of which will be will be monitored (due to spam) before showing on the blog.

PLEASE NOTE: By leaving a comment you consent to any personally identifiable information (such as name and avatar) being collected by Only Crumbs Remain. Alternatively, you may choose to mark your comment anonymous by making the relevant selection from the dropdown box in the comment field. A link to our full privacy Policy can be found at the bottom of the page.

Flick through our recipes!